Wisconsin Clean Elections Coalition

Promoting fair elections for all parties and independents

eNewsletter #7
(Mar 9, 2006)

This is a periodic newsletter on election and health care reform. If you wish not to receive it please unsubscribe at the bottom and accept my apologies for the intrusion.

In this issue:

1)  Gladwell vs Gladwell (a convert on single-payer health insurance)

2) Gladwell vs Gladwell (Continued) 

3) Upcoming Events

4) Let's throw the Rascals out!

5) Interesting Stories

6) Legislative Action Item

7) Book recommendations

8)     Contact Information

9)     Removal instructions

 

Please do not respond to this email address. It is used for cleanup purposes only. Please use jelohman@gmail.com

 

1

Gladwell vs Gladwell (on single-payer)

By DAN MITCHELL

SIX years ago in the Washington Monthly, Malcolm Gladwell faced off against Adam Gopnik, his fellow New Yorker writer, in a debate over Canada's single-payer health care system. Mr. Gopnik favored it; Mr. Gladwell opposed it vigorously. "Canada has achieved a wonderful thing, which is universal health care coverage," he said then. "But it has achieved it at a price, and that is quality of care."

On the blog he started last week (gladwell.typepad.com), Mr. Gladwell noted that the blogosphere has, for some mysterious reason, picked up on the debate. "But wait!" he wrote. "That was six years ago! I've now changed my mind. I now agree with virtually everything Adam said and disagree with virtually everything I said. In fact, I shudder when I read what I said back then."

In 2000, Mr. Gladwell recalled a bicycle accident he had at 16 in Ontario. "I ran off the road and I basically impaled my eye on a stick," he says. It took 9 days and a 120-mile trip to Toronto for him to get a CAT scan. The doctor declared that he "clearly suffered irreversible brain damage." His recovery, he said, was due more to luck than to the care he received.

In the United States then, CAT scan equipment proliferated. In Canada, it was rare. The United States is where medical discoveries are made. Countries like Canada don't make discoveries, they only benefit from those made in the United States. So argued Mr. Gladwell in 2000.

And now? By 2005, in a New Yorker article, Mr. Gladwell was arguing for health care reform with a vehemence he did not exhibit when he was on the other side of the question. One of the "great mysteries of political life in the United States is why Americans are so devoted" to a health care system "of increasing complexity and dysfunction," he wrote.

Why the change? "I woke up one day," he wrote in his blog, "and realized what much smarter people than me (Adam Gopnik) realized a long time ago, which is that the idea of employer-based health care is just plain stupid. And only our familiarity with it and sheer inertia prevent us from rising up in rebellion."

 

2
Gladwell vs Gladwell (Continued)

February 26, 2006

I [Gladwell] realize I forgot to provide a link to the long-ago debate between me and Adam Gopnik on the Canadian health care system. Here it is.

http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/features/2000/0003.gladwellgopnik.html

Why have I changed my mind? Some of my reasons are in the piece on moral hazard I wrote for the New Yorker last summer.

http://www.gladwell.com/2005/2005_08_29_a_hazard.html 

The bigger reason is simply that I woke up one day and realized what much smarter people than me (Adam Gopnik) realized a long time ago, which is that the idea of  employer-based health care is just plain stupid--and only our familiarity with it and sheer inertia prevent us from rising up in rebellion. I always try to think of a suitable analogy and fail. The closest I can come is to imagine if we had employer-based subways in New York. You could ride the subway if you had a job. But if you lost your job, you would either have to walk or pay a prohibitively expensive subway surcharge. Of course, if you lost your job you would need the subway more than ever, because you couldn't afford taxis and you would need to travel around looking for work. Right? In  any case, what logical connection is there between employment and transporation? If you can answer that question, you can solve the riddle of the U.S.health care system. And maybe I'll change my mind back. 

 

 

 

3
Upcoming Events

 

Grassroots North Shore: See dates and times at: http://www.grassrootsnorthshore.org/wb/pages/newsletter/all-members.php

Jim Hightower, Saturday March 18th at 7:00pm at the Phister (sponsored by the ACLU. Not my favorite group but most certainly my favorite speaker). $100 per person, order tickets at http://www.aclu-wi.org/get_involved/bill_of_rights_dinner/index.shtml 

Grassroots Citizens of Wisconsin: See this and other announcements at www.GrassrootsWisc.com

Join Jim Hopson, the plain-talking publisher of the Wisconsin State Journal, kicks off Cinnamon Rolls and Citizen Roles at 8:30am March 18 (to noon) at the Stonefield Apartments, 407 E. Madison, Dodgeville. Please RSVP to 608-623-2109

 

4
Let's throw the Rascals out!

 

Okay, so I cleaned it up a bit, but it is still a dream worth considering. And I'm talking about dislocating our state senators and assembly members, in case you are wondering.

No, I don't really think we can throw them all out, or even a major part of them. But we can indeed start giving them something to think seriously about. Right now there is no major movement to dislodge them, and they know it. They know full well that local promises and rhetoric on the right side of the issues will keep them in office, and their Madison votes will not get them thrown out. We must change that. Their cynical game is called "promise everything, deliver nothing" and will continue until we, the voters, interrupt it.

Where do we start?

  • By getting good candidates to challenge the incumbents. They have until mid-July to register.
  • By listing all contested seats and the challenger's name and website. Please send me all you have, regardless of party. Submit your challengers and we'll post them at www.ThrowTheRascalsOut.org (though I expect the number of challenges to be very small, and that's the problem).

Let's not leave even one uncontested seat! Only a public movement to throw them all out will get their attention.

Jack Lohman

In a democracy, elected officials serve the public best when they serve in fear of what might happen in the next election. That healthy fear of the electorate is lost when voters have little or no choice on the ballot. (from Power to the Voter http://www.wisdc.org/powertothevoter.php)

 

5
Interesting stories/Links

Political Use of Corporate Travel by PoliticalMoneyLine: In the last five years (2001-2005), Members of the U.S. House of Representatives and their leadership PACs, the leadership PACs of U.S. Senators, national party committees, and presidential candidate George Bush reported reimbursing corporations for air travel 2,154 times and valuing the cost of travel at $3,670,245.

See the story at: http://www.tray.com/cgi-win/indexhtml.exe?MBF=privateair

Porker of the Month: by Citizens Against Goverment Waste. Washington, D.C. Citizens Against Government Waste (CAGW) today named Deputy Assistant Secretary for Passport Services Frank Moss Porker of the Month.   Mr. Moss and the rest of the State Department decided to ignore the overwhelming public opposition to the use of passports containing radio frequency identification (RFID) chips.   The first e-passports are being distributed and the nationwide rollout will occur at the end of the year.    

 

[For those who are unfamiliar with RFID, it is like Wi-Fi. It broadcasts all personal information so that those standing nearby can read it with special devices. Having been a victim of identy theft, I oppose this technology (but support magnetic stripes).]

See story at: http://www.cagw.org/site/PageServer?pagename=news_porkerofthemonth

 

 

Don't miss this newdatabase on Congressional votes at: http://projects.washingtonpost.com/congress/ 

For Wisconsin members go to: http://projects.washingtonpost.com/congress/109/states/wi/

The $80 million Medicare Sellout!

Read it and weep at http://www.tompaine.com/articles/2006/03/01/the_80_billion_medicare_sellout.php

The Lobbying Game: Why the Revolving Door Won't Close: One Congressional staffer's moves back and forth from jobs on K Street to Capitol Hill show why it is so hard to change the lobbying culture in Washington

See story at:http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1160453,00.html

 

Scott Jenson testimony: http://www.madison.com/wsj/mad/top/index.php?ntid=75442&ntpid=1

 

6
Legislative Action Item (Please call your Rep/Sen)

From Wisconsin Democracy Campaign: With our ethics reform bill now headed to the full Assembly, please take a few minutes to contact your Assembly representative to urge support for Senate Bill 1. You can call the toll-free legislative hotline (1-800-362-9472 or 266-9960 in Madison ) or send a message by e-mail. For an e-mail directory for state representatives, go here. If you don't know your legislator, go here.

 

7
Book Recommendations

Read the reviews on www.amazon.com

The Good Fight: Declare YourIndependence and Close the Democracy Gap
by Ralph Nader (ISBN: 0060756047)
Heavily Liberal with thorough analysis, Nader likes neither party's actions or solutions and has excellent arguments and ideas.

Where the Right Went Wrong: How Neoconservatives Subverted the Reagan Revolution and Hijacked the Presidency
by Patrick J. Buchanan ( ISBN: 0312341156)
Conservative and mostly on target (though Buchanan fails to connect the dots to the moneyed interests, and doesn't seem to want to).

 

8
Contact information

 

Lohman is a retired business owner in Colgate WI and volunteers’ time on the issues of Election reform and Universal health care -

Contact: Jack Lohman

 

jelohman@gmail.com or jelohman@charter.net

Phone 414-477-8686 (cell)

www.WiCleanElections.org

www.wi-cfr.org

www.SmokeFreeDining.net

 

 

9
Removal Instructions

 

To leave the list, send a blank email to jelohman@gmail.com with “Remove” in the subject line

To subscribe, send a blank email to jelohman@gmail.com with “subscribe” in the subject line

The system is automatic and you must send from the email address you want added or removed.

If removed successfully you should receive a confirmation. If it fails please notify me directly at jelohman@gmail.com